As shoppers begin the hunt for holiday gifts, they face a familiar choice: buy from major retailers or from small businesses.
There are plenty of sentimental reasons to shop small, from finding one-of-a-kind gifts to supporting long-time neighborhood institutions. But does it actually make a difference when it comes to the economy?
According to Fordham economist Giacomo Santangelo, it does. Small businesses account for roughly 40% of U.S. economic activity and employ about 62 million people, or nearly half of the private-sector workforce, he said. Beyond their enormous economic footprint, they also help create a more competitive, resilient economy.
“The best we could hope for as consumers is more competition,” he said.
More Competition, More Choices
While large retailers can offer convenience and competitive prices, they also exercise considerable control over which products consumers can purchase, Santangelo said. Small businesses, meanwhile, can cater to more specialized interests and tastes.
Consider The NY Archive, a designer vintage store and collective in Chelsea founded by Fordham alumna Gianna Corvino ’22. What began as a collection of vintage designer shoes in her childhood bedroom has grown into a showroom featuring archival fashion, handbags, jewelry, and shoes from more than 20 independent dealers, many of them women-owned.
“With vintage especially, you’re buying something one-of-a-kind that was built to last, instead of something mass-produced and made to be replaced,” Corvino said.
The economic value of having more choices extends beyond variety in shopping. Santangelo noted that a community with many independent businesses is also less vulnerable to the failure of any one employer. When a single large retailer replaces numerous smaller stores, he explained, the local economy becomes increasingly dependent on that company and its closure can be catastrophic.
“If something happens to one of the small companies, there are several others there to meet the needs of the community,” he said.
Supporting Neighbors and Entrepreneurs
Small businesses also create opportunities for individuals to build wealth through entrepreneurship, Santangelo said. While running a business comes with substantial risks, ownership offers a potential path to financial independence that traditional employment may not.
For the Fordham alumni behind Queer Candle Co., the road to entrepreneurship began with a hobby. Ian Gibson ’16 and Alyssa Rose ’17 met at the Rose Hill campus in 2014 and started making candles in their New York City apartment in 2018. Today, the business supports both of them full time, with hand-poured soy candles produced in Philadelphia.
“Shopping at a small business—especially a two-person operation like ours—makes a material difference to the people running that business immediately,” Rose said.
That support matters now especially, as small businesses contend with rising costs, tariffs, and other economic pressures, Santangelo said.
For holiday shoppers, Santangelo’s message is to look beyond the convenience of major retailers and consider what might be lost when smaller businesses disappear. Supporting independent businesses can help preserve local ownership and the distinctive character of neighborhoods, he said.
“We’re helping our community stay our community,” Santangelo said. “And we don’t want to be fooled by the illusion of convenience—because that illusion is hiding something, like lack of choice.”
