In 1965, there were an estimated 60,000 Catholic priests living in the United States. By 2022, that number had dropped to around 35,000, even as the country’s population had grown by 100 million.
In a new documentary, Discerning the Call: Change in the American Priesthood, two Fordham students seek to explain why.
“Today, there are not as many men joining [the priesthood], and they join later,” said rising junior Jay Doherty, the film’s co-director.
“There are all sorts of different changes that have impacted the church and vocational discernment, and we wanted to tell the story of those changes through the lens of American history,” Doherty said.
Doherty, who majors in digital technologies and emerging media and philosophy, directed the film along with Patrick Cullihan, FCRH ’24, a fellow Duffy Fellow at Fordham’s Center on Religion and Culture. They conducted 30 hours of interviews with 27 priests, many of them residents of Fordham’s Jesuit communities. The film debuted in April at a Fordham Center on Religion and Culture event at the Howard Gilman Theater in Manhattan and is now available online.
High-profile Catholic leaders such as Cardinal Timothy Dolan and James Martin, S.J., editor at large at America magazine, make appearances, as does Fordham faculty member Bryan Massingale, S.T.D.
A Culture Long Gone
Cardinal Dolan spoke about how, in the years leading up to and during World War II, a strong “Catholic culture” made the vocation much more common than it is now. Catholics were born in their own hospitals, lived in predominantly Catholic neighborhoods, attended their own schools, and married other Catholics.
“With the collapse of the Catholic culture, that kind of external prop and encouragement to priestly vocations would have gone,” he said.
Dolan, who himself entered the seminary right out of high school, said that means fewer men are taking that path as teenagers.
“Now, the decision to become a priest would not be something imposed from the outside. It would not be something that would just be expected. It’s something that is a radical choice,” he said.
The priesthood has also been attracting more men who identify as theologically orthodox; the filmmakers note that a recent survey found the percentage of priests who identify as such increased from 20% in 1970 to 85% in 2020.
Stricter Requirements
Father Martin noted that one of the changes that affected recruitment into the Society of Jesus was stricter entrance requirements implemented in the 1960s. That resulted in fewer men joining, which some church leaders have welcomed, as it means those who do are more committed.
For the church to grow, though, Martin said leadership might have to also come from those in the pews.
“I think that the Holy Spirit might be calling lay people to a more active participation in the church,” he said in the film.
A Complex Issue
Father Massingale noted that many incorrectly assume the decline can be pinned on the church’s requirement that priests remain celibate.
“That’s certainly the case for a given segment, but it’s never been a complete explanation for all groups in the church,” he said, noting that racism also played a role.
“For many Black young men, another reason why they never entered the priesthood was because they were never asked.”
Doherty said the filmmakers wanted to include men spanning a wide range of ages, from 20-somethings to retired priests.
Each one had an intensely personal reason for joining, he said, noting that he hopes to create a second film from unused footage focusing on these stories. He’s also interested in stories from women religious.
In the meantime, the young directors are receiving recognition for their first film. It has been featured on SiriusXM’s Catholic Channel and WFUV, and in June, it was named the 2024 recipient of Fordham’s William F. DiPietra Award in Film.
Rediscovering Faith
For Doherty, the project has enabled him to explore his own faith.
“When I came to Fordham, I think I really rediscovered the faith and what it means to be Catholic,” he said.
“I had many interactions with Jesuits, and they were all so brilliant and interesting,” he said.
“I found myself wondering, ‘How did they come to this life?’”
