Mark Massa, SJ, a preeminent scholar of American Catholicism who was widely beloved for his generous mentorship and irreverent sense of humor, died of a heart attack on Nov. 15 in Spellman Hall, one of the University’s Jesuit residences. He was 76.

Father Massa had just begun the semester as the St. Ignatius Loyola Chair at Fordham while on sabbatical from Boston College. The year-long appointment brought him back to the University, where he was a theology professor for 23 years; the first holder of the Karl Rahner Chair in Theology; and the founding director of the Francis and Ann Curran Center for American Catholic Studies, now a nationally recognized hub for the study of American Catholic history, identity, and practice. 

“I can’t even imagine Fordham having this center for Catholic studies were it not for Mark,” said theology professor Michael E. Lee, PhD, its current director. The center is unique, he said, in that it offers both public programming as well as an undergraduate concentration in American Catholic studies that draws top students from across the University—and that is all because of Father Massa.

The diverse outcomes of the concentration’s more than 300 graduates—students who have pursued medicine, law, education, media, and political leadership—are a testament to Father Massa’s vision of forming talented undergraduates who would carry their Catholic tradition into the world, he said.

Angela Alaimo O’Donnell, PhD, associate director of the Curran Center, described Father Massa’s gravitational pull on students. “Even students who might not think the subject matter was something that they wanted to study knew they wanted to be in proximity to Mark’s intellect, his spirituality, his gravitas, his humor, and kindness.”

A Guiding Light

Jennifer Sawyer ’09 said Father Massa spurred her to think critically about the intersection of faith and culture—subjects she now covers as editor-in-chief of the Catholic media ministry Busted Halo. “The program made my faith come alive for the first time as an adult, and for that I’ll be forever grateful to him.”

James Fisher, who co-directed the Curran Center in its early years, called Father Massa’s charisma his unique gift. “I have never seen such universal adoration for a faculty member as I saw for him from students,” said the professor emeritus of theology. “He was completely oriented to bringing out the best of undergraduate students and to guiding them.”

Brenna Moore, ThD, theology professor and chair of the department, is one of many faculty members who also benefited from his guidance. 

“He was so much more than a scholar,” said Moore. “He was a wonderful friend, a great priest, and a generous mentor to so many.”

Finding His Calling

Father Massa with his sister Jamie in April

Mark Massa was born on Sept. 13, 1950, in Shadyside, Ohio, to Dolores Sbrissa Massa, a medical secretary, and Armand Francis Massa, a WWII veteran and accountant for Wheeling-Pittsburgh Steel.

His younger sister, Jamie Massa, said that her brother’s calling became clear around the 3rd or 4th grade, when he built an altar in his room. “We would play priest,” she said. The neighborhood kids would line up to receive communion from him via oyster crackers, and he sometimes asked them to go into a closet for confession, she said.

In high school he wrote a 65-page paper on the Spanish Inquisition and St. Ignatius of Loyola, she said, calling it a precursor to the eight books he authored, including Catholics and American Culture: Fulton Sheen, Dorothy Day, and the Notre Dame Football Team (1999), which won the Association for Jesuit Colleges and Universities/Alpha Sigma Nu Award for Outstanding Work in Theology; Anti-Catholicism in America: The Last Acceptable Prejudice (2005) and most recently, Catholic Fundamentalism in America (2025). 

Father Massa entered the Society of Jesus in 1968. He earned a bachelor’s from the University of Detroit and master’s degrees from the University of Chicago and the Weston Jesuit School of Theology. Following his ordination as a priest in 1980, he completed his doctorate in American religion at Harvard, then joined Fordham in 1987 as a faculty member in the theology department.

Measuring the Curran Center’s Success

From left: Joseph M. McShane, SJ, John and Constance Curran, and Mark Massa, SJ, at the launch of the Curran Center for American Catholic Studies in 2004.

Joseph O’Hare, SJ, then president of Fordham, tapped Father Massa to create a center for American Catholic studies, which launched in 2001. “The program at Fordham will be a place where Catholic intellectuals can do their thinking,’ Massa said at the time in Fordham Magazine. “We’re trying to rethink ways to provide faculty and students with a locus for talking about Catholic issues with an interdisciplinary perspective.”

Father Massa left Fordham in 2011 to serve as the dean of the School of Theology and Ministry at Boston College. He directed their Boisi Center for Religion and American Public Life for the past 10 years. Photo: Boston College/John Gillooly

He was a natural choice given his expertise in the historical development of Catholicism in the United States and how this centuries-old religion became distinctly American, said O’Donnell. Our separation of church and state was one major differentiator from European Catholicism, she points out, as were the multiple immigrant groups who brought their own manifestation of Catholicism to the U.S., where they were free to practice it.

Drawing upon his scholarship and his 14 years of experience directing Fordham’s interdisciplinary American Studies program, Father Massa developed the curriculum for the concentration. “It’s such a good template for students that we’re still using it 26 years later,” she said.

Generous donations from benefactors, including Ruth and Michael Lipper and the late John Curran ’66 and his wife, Connie, secured the center’s future. In 2004, it was renamed in honor of John’s parents following the Currans’ naming endowment. At its 17th anniversary celebration, Connie shared a message of gratitude.

“Mark put in place the foundation and the direction for his future successors,” she said. “Those footprints, along with great leadership, enabled the center to achieve growth and recognition as a premier center for American Catholic studies.”

During the event, Father Massa expressed his pride in the center’s accomplishments. “The General of the Society of Jesus has said the measure of success of Jesuit schools is not how much money our graduates make but by the kind of persons they are,” he said. “By that measure, the Curran Center has been a wildly successful center.”

Father Massa decorated his office door at Fordham with humorous religious cartoons and photos. One depicts a bumper sticker that reads: Would you follow Jesus this closely?

A Man of Many Massa-isms

Father Massa’s humor was legendary. 

“If you were seated next to Mark at a dinner, you knew you were going to have a great night,” said Moore. 

He had so many quips in rotation, students kept a running list of his “Massa-isms.”

Both Sawyer and Daniel Cosachi ’08, now vice president for mission and ministry at the University of Scranton, fondly recalled Massa saying: “You’re my favorite; don’t tell the others.” (Cosachi relayed many more Massa-isms in the obituary he wrote for America.) 

Always More to Say

O’Donnell had dinner with Father Massa at Spellman Hall a week before his death. 

“Mark had a very restless spirit,” she said. “He was always thinking of new projects.” At 76, he was working on a new book about different manifestations of American Catholicism through Catholic artists and activists, including Dorothy Day, Thomas Merton, and Flannery O’Connor. The fact that others have written about these figures did not daunt him, she said. 

“That was very characteristic of Mark’s way of thinking—that there’s always more that can be said.”

Father Massa is survived by his sister, Jamie, and brother-in-law Stuart Hobbs; niece Sarah Hobbs; grandniece Crew Sutton Hobbs; and his Jesuit brothers. His scheduled services are as follows—Wake: Monday, Nov. 23, from 9 a.m. to 12 p.m. and again from 2 to 5 p.m., in the conference room at St. Mary’s Hall, Boston College. Vigil: Nov. 23 from 7 to 8 p.m. at St. Ignatius Loyola Church, 28 Commonwealth Ave., Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts. A Mass of Christian Burial: Tuesday, Nov. 24, 10 a.m. St. Ignatius Loyola Church, with a repast following the Eucharist on the Lower Campus of Boston College, near the church. Burial: 2 p.m., Jesuit Cemetery, Campion Center, 319 Concord Rd., Weston, Massachusetts.

Share.

Nicole Davis is Assistant Director of Internal Communications at Fordham. She can be reached at [email protected].