Soon Black Friday will arrive, kicking off the holiday shopping season—or for some of us, the overshopping season, followed by a financial “hangover” in January. When the promotions kick into gear and the warm holiday aura casts its spell, how can we control our spending? Two professors from Fordham’s Gabelli School of Business offered advice, drawing from research into consumer behavior and how it can shift during the most wonderful time of the year.
Tip No. 1: Make a List and Check It Twice. (Or as Often as You Need.)
Amid the nostalgia and fond memories stirred by the holiday season, “our minds are really powerful” in justifying extra spending, swayed by the idea that “it happens just one time a year,” said Hoori Rafieian, PhD, a marketing professor who studies self-control and motivation. Combine that with numerous targeted ad campaigns, as well as social pressure to buy more gifts, and willpower wilts. “It’s one of the most unreliable tools,” Rafieian said.
A more reliable tool: the humble shopping list, preferably one drawn up in the pre-holidays calm. It’s not 100% effective, but research shows that “the amount of unplanned purchases goes down substantially” when shoppers proactively draw up a plan of what they’ll buy and try to stick to it, she said.
Tip No. 2: Be Mindful and Intentional About Your Shopping.
Merchants will gradually raise a product’s price over time and drop it again for a holiday “discount.” Or they may create a sense of urgency with an “only three left in stock” message. Rafieian advised focusing on the product’s inherent value apart from the sales tactic, asking yourself “would I buy this normally?”
Similarly, she advised being aware of buy-now, pay-later tactics common during the holidays. Recent research shows that when given this option, shoppers will spend more than they would have otherwise, Rafieian said.
Tip No. 3: For Saving Money, Friction Is Your Friend.
Weaving small delays and extra efforts, or “friction,” into the process is a proven tactic for controlling spending. That could mean keying in your credit card number with every online purchase, rather than letting it be stored in a web browser or a retailer’s site, Rafieian said. Or stick to a fixed budget, either by keeping a running total in a spreadsheet or doing all your holiday shopping with a prepaid credit card in the total amount you’re willing to spend, she said.
The physical work of shopping in a store rather than online could do the trick too. “The more friction there is, the less we spend. There is a ton of evidence behind that,” Rafieian said.
Tip No. 4: Look Out for Words That Sway Your Spending.
During the holidays, phrases abound that prime us to spend and even create pressure to do so, said Dawn Lerman, PhD, a marketing professor who studies the role of language in consumer behavior. Messages like “the art of giving” and “the joy of giving” create the mood, and messages like “choose the perfect gift” subtly raise the stakes—making the retailer’s gift catalog seem like a welcome solution. “I think it’s well worth being aware of the language that retailers are using” and the emotions they evoke so you can sidestep any feeling of pressure, she said.
Tip No. 5: Watch the ‘Colorful’ Language.
Packaging creates a language all its own, and packaging distinctive to this time of year can tap into the spending spirit, Lerman said. It so happens that red, the traditional Christmas color, has been shown to “literally make our heart beat faster” and encourage us to spend, she said, noting the red coffee cups that Starbucks rolls out at this time of year. Red is “just associated with energy and excitement”—which, during the holidays, can translate into “buying lots of gifts,” she said.
